Saturn rear-ended at low speed, but back still hurts

Discussion in 'General Motoring' started by Rich Wales, Oct 27, 2004.

  1. Rich Wales

    Rich Wales Guest

    Any thoughts or comments about the following?

    About six weeks ago, I (driving a '99 Saturn SL2) was rear-ended
    while trying to leave a parking lot. I was stopped at a red light,
    inched out a bit to see my way clear for a right turn, and the
    driver who was stopped behind me (in a Dodge Grand Caravan)
    apparently put her foot on the gas (!) instead of the brake.

    The impact, from my POV, was very loud, sudden, and forceful --
    definitely =not= a "love tap" -- and I felt like something had
    pushed hard against the middle of my back, and that the wind had
    been knocked out of me. I fully expected to find the rear end of
    my Saturn reduced to a crumpled mess -- but, to my surprise, there
    was almost no visible damage at all (just some deforming of the
    plastic rear bumper cover).

    Subsequent repairs (done by a body shop recommended to me by the
    nearby Saturn retailer) came to roughly $800. The body shop
    people said they had checked for other damage but found none.

    I didn't hit anything (there was no car in front of me, and I was
    not pushed out into traffic; I had my foot on the brake at the
    instant of the collision, BTW). Thus, there was no front-end
    damage at all, and the air bags did =not= go off.

    I've had lower back pain ever since the accident. Not searing,
    stabbing, intolerable pain, thankfully -- more like a very sore
    feeling at, and below, my belt line. My doctor had it X-rayed,
    but this revealed only normal degeneration (I'm 52). He says
    it's probably a sprain of the lumbar region. I've been sent
    to a physical therapy clinic; I've had one session (mild back
    exercise, plus electrical stimulation and ice) and have been
    prescribed six more (twice a week for the next three weeks).

    Thankfully, I do not seem to have suffered any neck or head
    injury. I was wearing my seat belt (I'm guessing that the "wind
    knocked out of me" sensation may have been from my body being
    thrown against the shoulder belt). I didn't lose consciousness,
    and my head definitely did =not= whip forward or strike anything.

    In case it matters any, I was rear-ended six years ago (more
    forcefully than this time). Although it took quite a long time
    for my back to heal from that incident, I did eventually get
    better, and I was no longer having back pain by the time I was
    rear-ended last month (i.e., the pain from this accident is
    definitely =not= simply a continuation of pain from the earlier
    accident).

    The other driver's insurance company (Allstate) has admitted
    liability for the collision -- it would of course be very hard
    for them not to! -- but since there was so little damage to my
    car, they're making noises to the effect that they intend to
    treat my injury claim as a "minor impact case", involving only
    minimal discomfort, and that they plan to agree only to a modest
    reimbursement for doctor bills. (I have not yet made any demand
    or agreed to any settlement for my injuries, BTW.)

    Some questions:

    Given that the impact apparently did not bend the frame or cause
    significant damage (other than cosmetic damage) to my Saturn's
    rear end, is there any way to do a rough guess of how fast the
    Caravan might have been going when it hit me? (I know Saturns
    are supposed to have 5-mph bumpers, but does that necessarily
    mean that a collision faster than 5 mph =will= result in damage
    to more than just the bumper?)

    The body shop (supposed to be a very good shop, and recommended
    to me by the nearby Saturn dealer's service department after I
    expressed concern that I wanted to be very sure my car would be
    repaired right) insisted there was no frame or body damage. I'd
    assume that they're probably right -- if by any chance they were
    dishonest or incompetent, I'd imagine they'd be more inclined to
    claim there was more damage rather than less -- and the car does
    appear to handle just fine as far as I can tell -- but is there
    any reasonable way to confirm that my vehicle really is (or is
    not) fine?

    Has anyone else out there had long-lasting lower back injury
    from what appeared to be a minor, slow-speed rear-end collision?
    How long did it take for your back to heal? What did you have
    to do to get long-term relief from the pain? Were you able to
    get the other person's insurance company to believe the true
    extent of your injury and give you a proper settlement, and if
    so, how did you do it?

    Rich Wales http://www.richw.org
     
    Rich Wales, Oct 27, 2004
    #1
Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments (here). After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.