1996 SL1 Difficulty Starting - Solenoid Location/Other Thoughts?

[Bob Shuman]

My son is experiencing a problem starting his '96 SL1. He says the engine
seems to turn over slowly so won't start, then after cranking for a few
seconds, starts normally. He says this happens more frequently when weather
is colder and has been happening "on and off" for the last 3 or so weeks.

He is away at school, and at my request he took it in to check the battery
and charging system since it sounded like a weak battery to me. They
confirmed a bad battery, but said the charging system was OK. He replaced
the battery, and cleaned the cables thoroughly before re-attaching, but had
the problem re-appear the following day. I also know that all the vehicle
grounds from the negative to the frame, engine, etc. are good since I had
removed and wire brushed every one of these last summer while working a
ignition misfire "check engine"service light/code.

At this point, I am thinking this could be a starter solenoid issue since
the starter and solenoid are still original equipment and have seen 140K
miles and 11 years of use. Can anyone tell me where the solenoid is located
on this model? (Sorry to ask, but the vehicle is not here for me to follow
the wiring myself...) I do not believe it is an ignition switch or starter
relay issue since he said it turns over and tries to start when he turns the
key.

Responses appreciated on the location and any other thoughts on what I can
check when he gets the vehicle back home for me to look at it. Thanks in
advance.

Bob

 

[Doug Miller]

My son is experiencing a problem starting his '96 SL1. He says the engine
seems to turn over slowly so won't start, then after cranking for a few
seconds, starts normally. He says this happens more frequently when weather
is colder and has been happening "on and off" for the last 3 or so weeks.

He is away at school, and at my request he took it in to check the battery
and charging system since it sounded like a weak battery to me. They
confirmed a bad battery, but said the charging system was OK. He replaced
the battery, and cleaned the cables thoroughly before re-attaching, but had
the problem re-appear the following day. I also know that all the vehicle
grounds from the negative to the frame, engine, etc. are good since I had
removed and wire brushed every one of these last summer while working a
ignition misfire "check engine"service light/code.

At this point, I am thinking this could be a starter solenoid issue [snip]

No.

Starter solenoid won't affect cranking speed. The starter *motor* may be
wearing out, but if the starter cranks the engine at all, the solenoid is
good.

Responses appreciated on the location and any other thoughts on what I can
check when he gets the vehicle back home for me to look at it. Thanks in
advance.

You said he replaced the battery, and the problem recurred the following day.
A new battery doesn't go bad overnight. My first thought is that the guy who
checked the charging system is incompetent -- the alternator or voltage
regulator is going south, or the belt is loose -- and you should have the
charging system checked out again by a different shop.

If that checks out OK the second time around, look for something that's
draining the battery overnight: interior light left on, sagging brake pedal
turning on the brake lights, or who knows what. Maybe he has some sort of
accessory plugged into the cig lighter socket that's draining current?

How long since the last oil change, and what type of oil was put in? You said
the weather is getting "colder".. but that's a relative term. Where are you?
"Cold" to you might be "balmy" to me, or vice versa. "Cold" to the *car* means
freezing or below. It might help to change the oil with 5W30 -- but make sure
to get that out of there, and put 10W30 in, before summer.

 

[Bob Shuman]

Doug,

Thanks for the response. Comments are inserted below. I've done a bit more
research and see that the solenoid is attached to the starter motor assembly
and is not a separate component. As such, if all the fuses, wires and
connections check out good/clean/tight, then the most obvious thing to do
would be to replace the starter with a rebuilt unit since this covers the
situation regardless of whether it is being caused by the starter motor or
the solenoid.

Thanks again for taking the time to respond with your thoughts.

Bob

My son is experiencing a problem starting his '96 SL1. He says the engine
seems to turn over slowly so won't start, then after cranking for a few
seconds, starts normally. He says this happens more frequently when
weather
is colder and has been happening "on and off" for the last 3 or so weeks.

He is away at school, and at my request he took it in to check the battery
and charging system since it sounded like a weak battery to me. They
confirmed a bad battery, but said the charging system was OK. He replaced
the battery, and cleaned the cables thoroughly before re-attaching, but
had
the problem re-appear the following day. I also know that all the vehicle
grounds from the negative to the frame, engine, etc. are good since I had
removed and wire brushed every one of these last summer while working a
ignition misfire "check engine"service light/code.

At this point, I am thinking this could be a starter solenoid issue [snip]

No.

Starter solenoid won't affect cranking speed. The starter *motor* may be
wearing out, but if the starter cranks the engine at all, the solenoid is
good.

I disagree with this statement and have seen resistive solenoid contacts (in
other vehicles) cause a reduction in available cranking current resulting in
reduced voltage at the starter motor causing the same symptoms he claims to
be seeing.

You said he replaced the battery, and the problem recurred the following
day.
A new battery doesn't go bad overnight. My first thought is that the guy
who
checked the charging system is incompetent -- the alternator or voltage
regulator is going south, or the belt is loose -- and you should have the
charging system checked out again by a different shop.

I had thought the same thing, and he went back and re-tested the battery and
charging system at a second service garage and they said both the battery
and alternator looked good. This is why I don't suspect the new battery is
bad and believe the alternator is in fact working properly as well. (I knew
these are a common failure on Saturn's so had suspected that first.)

If that checks out OK the second time around, look for something that's
draining the battery overnight: interior light left on, sagging brake
pedal
turning on the brake lights, or who knows what. Maybe he has some sort of
accessory plugged into the cig lighter socket that's draining current?

As expalined above, the new battery does not appear to being drained. (I
had asked my son the same question when he first reported the symptoms, but
since the battery was 4 years old, suggested he have it tested and
replaced.) I'll hopefully get a chance to see this for myself if he drives
home from school over the weekend. I plan to measure battery voltage with
the vehicle off when he arrives and again when the car is running and the
alternator is charging the battery. Based on his being able to drive it now
for a couple days and running headlights at night, radio, heater blower,
etc. I tend to believe the two independent diagnosis that the charging
system and battery are now working correctly.

How long since the last oil change, and what type of oil was put in? You
said
the weather is getting "colder".. but that's a relative term. Where are
you?
"Cold" to you might be "balmy" to me, or vice versa. "Cold" to the *car*
means
freezing or below. It might help to change the oil with 5W30 -- but make
sure
to get that out of there, and put 10W30 in, before summer.

I do change the oil from 10W30 to 5W30 for the winter in all of our vehicles
since temperatures can reach -20 degrees F here in the Chicago area during
winter. Right now the temperature is about 40 degrees F so I doubt this is
the issue. The oil was scheduled to be changed to 5W30 when he was home for
Thanksgiving in a couple weeks. I've never seen a problem in any vehiclke
with temperature above 0 degrees F, and would think that the Saturn's small
4 cylinder would make it even easier to turn. That said, we may change the
oil sooner if he gets home to fix the starter.

Thanks.

 

[Doug Miller]

As expalined above, the new battery does not appear to being drained.

Incorrect. You've explained that the new battery does appear to be getting
charged -- but you haven't described any testing or investigation you've done
to make sure that charge isn't getting drained off overnight by some load that
shouldn't be there (interior light left on, for example).

Before replacing the starter, I think you should make three voltage
measurements on the battery: just before starting the engine, just after
shutting the engine off after driving the car for a while -- and after it's
been sitting in the driveway overnight. If there's a substantial difference
between the three, particularly if the last measurement is much lower than the
other two, then it's time to start looking for whatever's draining the battery
overnight.

 

[Doug Miller]

Doug,

Thanks for the response. Comments are inserted below. I've done a bit more
research and see that the solenoid is attached to the starter motor assembly
and is not a separate component.

As it is on ALL starter motors...

[snip]

I disagree with this statement and have seen resistive solenoid contacts (in
other vehicles) cause a reduction in available cranking current resulting in
reduced voltage at the starter motor causing the same symptoms he claims to
be seeing.

Disagree all you like -- you're still mistaken. You've described a problem
caused by corrosion, not a bad solenoid. The solenoid is nothing more than an
electromagnet that moves the starter pinion gear into position where it
contacts the flywheel. The symptom of a good starter motor and a bad solenoid
is that the starter motor spins when you turn the ignition key -- but the
engine does NOT; hence my statement that if the starter cranks the engine at
all, the solenoid is good.

 

[Bob Shuman]

Additional comments inline below.

Bob

Disagree all you like -- you're still mistaken. You've described a problem
caused by corrosion, not a bad solenoid. The solenoid is nothing more than
an
electromagnet that moves the starter pinion gear into position where it
contacts the flywheel. The symptom of a good starter motor and a bad
solenoid
is that the starter motor spins when you turn the ignition key -- but the
engine does NOT; hence my statement that if the starter cranks the engine
at
all, the solenoid is good.

Again, I respectfully disagree with your statement that "the solenoid is
nothing more than an
electromagnet that moves the starter pinion gear into position where it
contacts the flywheel." While it is indeed true that the solenoid is indeed
an electromagnet that is energized by turning the ignition key, which in
most cases closes the starter relay circuit, it actually serves as the final
connection for the high amperage current directly from the 12V battery.
This is accomplished when the solenoid gets energized and pulls down a
conductive copper plunger that shorts across two copper contacts and
energizes the circuit to the starter motor armature, thereby turning the
engine.

Here is a URL with a site that includes photos for a Nippondenso
starter/solenoid for which I have removed and replaced worn out contacts on
four separate occassions and 4 separate Chrysler vehicles:

http://www.4crawler.com/4x4/CheapTricks/Starter.shtml

With regard to your comment that you feel this is caused by corrosion, this
could in fact be very true. My point is that the solenoid plunger and
contact surfaces wear and eventually can lead to intermittant starting
problems like my son is seeing. If the contacts become resistive (this only
requires it be tenths of an ohm), then the reduced current and accompanying
voltage drop can produce symptoms that emulate dirty/corroded battery or
ground contacts. In addition, just like with the dirty battery contacts,
the high current drawn through the resistive connection can "burn through"
the source of the resistance which coupled with this being an physical
contact of the conductive surfaces, leads to the intermittant and
unpredictable nature of this beast.

That all said, I do agree with your recommendations on the battery
measurements in a previous post and appreciate that input. Given that my
son has been driving the vehicle now several days/nights and using his
electrical accessories (headlights, stereo, heater blower, rear defroster)
normally since the 4-year old battery was replaced, I am inclined to
believe the two separate service garages that gave their Ok to the
alternator/charging system and the second one that verified the charge on
the new battery was also good.

My plan at this point is to verify the following in the order given and if
all look good, then I'll go ahead and replace the starter (which has the
solenoid attached - by the way, on a side note this was not true of all
vehciles I've worked on over the years) :

1. Make recommended battery measurements to assure system is charging
battery properly
2. Verify all connections at battery and starter are clean and tight
3. Verify chasis and engine block ground cable connection clean and tight
4. Verify there is no internal cable corrosion and measure cable resistance
5. Remove starter, open and examine starter solenoid contacts (Replace unit
w/rebuilt)

Thanks again.

 

[Doug Miller]

My plan at this point is to verify the following in the order given and if
all look good, then I'll go ahead and replace the starter (which has the
solenoid attached - by the way, on a side note this was not true of all
vehciles I've worked on over the years) :

With all due respect, yes, it is true of all vehicles you've ever worked on.
You appear to be confusing the starter solenoid with the starter *relay*,
which often *is* a separate unit, particularly on Chrysler vehicles such as
you referred to -- and is frequently referred to, albeit mistakenly, by
many auto parts store employees, mechanics, and DIYers as the solenoid. The
solenoid is *always* integrated with the starter. It has to be, because it's
the part that moves the pinion gear into position. It's impossible for the
solenoid to not be part of the starter.

1. Make recommended battery measurements to assure system is charging
battery properly

And is not being drained overnight!

2. Verify all connections at battery and starter are clean and tight
3. Verify chasis and engine block ground cable connection clean and tight
4. Verify there is no internal cable corrosion and measure cable resistance
5. Remove starter, open and examine starter solenoid contacts (Replace unit
w/rebuilt)

Post again when you've found the problem. It may well be the starter motor
(although I'm betting on something that's draining the battery). But it is
*not* the starter solenoid.

 

[Bob Shuman]

I do know the difference between a starter relay and a starter solenoid. On
Chryslers, the relay energizes the solenoid which makes the final high
amperage contact for the starter motor. Look at the site I provided. The
pictures show the copper contact surfaces and how they get degraded with
use.

The Saturn uses a Valeo PMGR starter. If you care to do a google search,
you will find similar pictures of the solenoid plunger and contactor for
that starter as well.

I will let you know the outcome. I think I have what I need at this point.

Bob

 

[Bob Shuman]

As promised, here is what I believe is the final outcome for this posting.

My son brought the car home on Saturday morning. Since we suspected
battery/charging problems, I measured the battery voltage after he arrived
(12.8V) and again with the engine running and the alternator charging the
battery (14.8V). My son tried to duplicate the starting problems that
evening with the engine warm, but could not. I did notice though that the
car seemed to be idling a bit fast (~1000RPM) so we cleaned out the throttle
body to see if that would have any impact, but did not appear to help.

The next morning before the car had been started, I re-measured the battery
voltage with the engine off and it was still 12.8V. I then concluded the
problem wasn't the battery draining or alternator related for that matter
either. When we started the car, it took a while to start, but the starter
turned over the engine at what appeared to me to be normal speed. My son
then said that this symptom of not starting was exactly the problem he was
seeing. He pushed the accelerator to the floor and the car started up, but
the idle jumped to 1500RPM. Even after running for 10 minutes, the
temperature gauge still showed Cold and the RPM was still hovering around
1050 and when I gave it gas we saw a slight hesitation.

Based on what I have read in this newsgroup over the years and the symptoms,
I immediately suspected the Coolant Temperature Sensor. We visited the
local auto parts store and bought a brass replacement unit and some high
temp thread sealant.

We did the replacement and for good measure I sprayed electrical contact
cleaner into the connector. When done, we topped off the antifreeze/coolant
since a small amount was lost during the swap. When done, we re-started the
engine and all seemed good and it ran well. The gauge was working again and
the engine idled around 850 with the engine is warm. I am hoping that this
is what was causing the problem and he just left to drive back to school.

After he left, I looked a the part we removed and see that the plastic
sealed part that sits inside the engine head was cracked so this must have
caused the failure.

I also noticed that his gas purchase/miles traveled per tank showed a 25%
decrease in mileage over the last month. This further supported that this
has been an issue for some time. Lastly, when we removed and looked at the
spark plugs, they were carbon fouled indicating it was running rich.

Doug, thanks again for your input. I'm betting this was the issue and
hopefully he will be better able to convey symptoms in the future now that
he knows what to look for.

Bob